BYU Escapes Utah Upset Bid in Thrilling Holy War Victory
In a dramatic Holy War rivalry matchup, BYU narrowly escaped an upset by Utah, edging out a 22-21 victory at Rice-Eccles Stadium. With their undefeated season on the line, the Cougars found themselves in a tense battle against the Utes, ultimately benefiting from a crucial holding call in the game’s final minutes to secure their win. This victory keeps BYU at the top of the Big 12 standings and in strong contention for a College Football Playoff berth.
First Half: Utah Controls Early Momentum
The rivalry atmosphere was intense, and Utah used the energy of the home crowd to establish dominance in the first half. Quarterback Brandon Rose displayed confidence, leading the Utes to a 21-10 halftime lead. Utah’s balanced offense created numerous problems for BYU’s defense, as Rose connected with his top targets for significant gains, including a critical 25-yard touchdown pass to tight end Thomas Yassmin.
The Utes also effectively utilized their ground game, with running back Micah Bernard exploiting gaps in BYU’s defense. Behind a sturdy offensive line, Bernard consistently found room to run, allowing Utah to control the clock and keep BYU’s offense off the field. With a strong first-half showing, Utah looked poised to secure an upset over their in-state rival.
BYU Struggles to Find Offensive Rhythm
Throughout the game’s first three quarters, BYU’s offense struggled to gain momentum. Quarterback Jake Retzlaff faced significant pressure from Utah’s defensive line, which disrupted the Cougars’ passing game. Retzlaff, who finished the game with 219 passing yards, faced limited success against Utah’s secondary. The Utes’ aggressive defensive approach forced BYU into several third-and-long situations, further stalling their offensive drives.
Despite the offensive struggles, BYU’s defense made key plays to keep them within reach. Defensive lineman Tyler Batty and linebacker Isaiah Glasker applied pressure on Rose, managing to disrupt Utah’s drives at critical moments. Though they faced an uphill battle, BYU’s defense held Utah scoreless in the third quarter, setting the stage for a tense final period.
BYU’s Comeback and Controversial Call
In the fourth quarter, BYU managed to rally with time running out. Trailing by two points and starting a final drive deep within their territory, BYU moved forward cautiously. Retzlaff managed several short completions, gradually advancing the Cougars up the field. On a pivotal fourth down, Utah’s defense appeared to secure the stop they needed, sacking Retzlaff to seemingly end BYU’s hopes.
However, a defensive holding penalty against Utah overturned the play, allowing BYU to continue their drive. Capitalizing on the new set of downs, Retzlaff connected on critical passes to Chase Roberts and Darius Lassiter, bringing BYU within striking distance. Running back Hinckley Ropati then broke through Utah’s defense, setting up BYU in range for a game-winning field goal.
With three seconds left on the clock, BYU kicker Will Ferrin delivered the deciding 44-yard field goal, sealing the Cougars' narrow victory. The dramatic ending and controversial call added to the intensity of an already heated rivalry, with BYU preserving its undefeated season and holding onto its position as the top team in the Big 12.
Postgame Reactions and Implications
The close call with Utah has stirred significant conversation among fans and analysts. BYU’s win, marked by the crucial holding penalty, has brought renewed attention to officiating in high-stakes games. Discussions about the call have dominated social media and sports commentary, with opinions divided on whether it was warranted. The timing and impact of the decision underscore the unpredictable nature of rivalry games and the high-pressure atmosphere surrounding every play.
For BYU, this victory keeps them at a perfect 9-0 on the season and 6-0 in the Big 12. With upcoming games against Kansas, Arizona State, and Houston, the Cougars are on track for a Big 12 Championship appearance and possibly a College Football Playoff berth. Their ability to overcome a challenging situation on the road highlights their resilience and adds depth to their resume as they aim to finish the season without a loss.
Utah, now at 4-5, has seen its bowl eligibility hopes narrow. Despite the setback, the Utes demonstrated their capability to compete with a highly ranked opponent, showcasing a balanced offensive attack and a tenacious defense. Although their season may not yield a title or high-ranking finish, Utah’s performance against BYU reflects the strength of their program and the potential for future success as they continue to develop their roster.







