Volleyball Trans Player Controversy: Teams Refusing to Play San Jose State Over Inclusion of Transgender Athlete
San Jose State University’s women’s volleyball team is facing significant controversy as multiple teams have refused to play them due to the inclusion of Blaire Fleming, a transgender athlete on their roster. The situation has escalated throughout the season, with four teams already forfeiting their matches against San Jose State, igniting a heated debate over fairness and inclusion in college sports.
Mountain West Commissioner Speaks Out on Growing Controversy
Mountain West Conference commissioner Gloria Nevarez expressed heartbreak and frustration over the situation, which has dominated headlines and created division among teams. Nevarez addressed the controversy on Thursday, stating that while schools like Boise State, Utah State, Wyoming, and Southern Utah have forfeited, none of the institutions have publicly provided specific reasons for their decisions. However, it is widely speculated that the forfeitures stem from protest over Fleming’s participation as a transgender athlete in women’s volleyball.
Nevarez emphasized that the forfeit decisions not only affect the standings but also carry significant consequences for teams hoping to qualify for the Mountain West Conference tournament, which will take place in Las Vegas in late November. Any team that refuses to play San Jose State will automatically record a loss, jeopardizing their chances of advancing in the conference.
Nevada Set to Forfeit Over Transgender Athlete
The controversy is set to continue as San Jose State prepares to face Nevada on October 26. However, the Nevada Wolf Pack women’s volleyball team has already indicated they will forfeit the match. A statement released by a group of Nevada players highlighted concerns about "safety and fair competition," with the athletes choosing not to compete against San Jose State. Despite the university’s insistence that state laws prohibit discrimination based on gender identity, the team’s decision has already drawn national attention.
Nevada’s refusal to play presents a major challenge for the institution, as the forfeit could impact their standing within the Mountain West Conference. While the players are permitted to opt-out individually without facing penalties, the university remains firm that only the institution can officially cancel a scheduled match. As a result, the Nevada team’s decision to forfeit places them in a precarious position heading into the final weeks of the season.
Blaire Fleming at the Center of Debate
Blaire Fleming, the transgender athlete at the heart of the controversy, has been an integral part of San Jose State’s volleyball team. Despite the criticism and growing protest from opposing teams, Fleming has continued to perform at a high level. In a recent match against New Mexico, her powerful spike sent a ball flying across the net, causing an opposing player to stumble. San Jose State won the match 3-1, marking their first win since September 24.
Fleming’s role in the team’s success has garnered both support and backlash. Advocates of transgender inclusion have defended the NCAA’s policies, which allow transgender athletes to compete, provided they meet certain hormone requirements. Critics, however, argue that Fleming’s participation creates an unfair advantage in women’s volleyball, leading to forfeits from teams who feel uncomfortable competing under these conditions.
Despite the controversy swirling around her, Fleming has played a pivotal role for San Jose State this season, having transferred from Coastal Carolina three years ago. Her contributions on the court have helped the team remain competitive even as the controversy continues to grow.
Political Pressure Surrounds the Issue
The forfeitures have ignited a national debate, with political figures and activists weighing in on the inclusion of transgender athletes in women’s sports. Republican governors from Idaho, Utah, and Nevada have publicly backed the teams that opted out of their scheduled matches against San Jose State, voicing support for their decisions to forfeit. Former President Donald Trump also commented on the matter during a town hall appearance, referencing the broader debate surrounding transgender athletes.
San Jose State has refrained from directly addressing the political statements, with head coach Todd Kress remaining focused on his players. Kress has described the volleyball court as a "safe haven" for the athletes amid the turmoil, but acknowledged that the growing controversy has impacted the team’s morale. Players have reportedly received hateful messages, and additional security measures, including police escorts, have been implemented for the team during games.
The Impact on San Jose State’s Season
Despite the distractions off the court, San Jose State’s volleyball team continues to compete. The Spartans recorded a critical win over New Mexico, and they remain focused on their upcoming schedule, which includes matches against Air Force and the potentially forfeited contest against Nevada.
If Nevada follows through with their forfeit on October 26, they will be the fifth team this season to refuse to play San Jose State due to the presence of Blaire Fleming. These forfeitures could have a significant impact on the Mountain West Conference standings, with the forfeiting teams risking their positions in the conference tournament.
The controversy shows no signs of slowing down, and with the Mountain West Conference tournament approaching in November, the decisions made by these teams could have lasting ramifications for the competition and the broader discussion around transgender athletes in sports.
Looking Ahead
As the volleyball season moves forward, San Jose State will continue to compete in the face of adversity, with Blaire Fleming at the center of the debate. The team is set to play Air Force next, followed by the likely forfeited match against Nevada. Whether other teams will choose to forfeit their matches remains uncertain, but the controversy has clearly taken on a national dimension, with opinions divided on both sides of the issue.
San Jose State’s resolve will be tested as they navigate this tumultuous season, but the Spartans remain focused on finishing strong and competing for a spot in the Mountain West Conference tournament.







