NIL Promises Unfulfilled: UNLV Loses Starting QB as NIL Chaos Grows
UNLV starting quarterback Matthew Sluka has made headlines after announcing his departure from the team just three games into an undefeated season. The quarterback, who transferred from Holy Cross, decided to sit out the remainder of the season after promises surrounding his Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) compensation allegedly went unfulfilled. This decision highlights a growing issue within college athletics, where disputes over NIL deals are becoming increasingly common and problematic.
Sluka’s Exit from UNLV
After leading UNLV to an impressive 3-0 start, Matthew Sluka’s decision to leave the team shocked fans and raised questions about the state of NIL agreements in college football. Sluka was reportedly promised a six-figure payday upon joining the Rebels, but according to his representatives, those promises were never met. Instead, Sluka only received a $3,000 relocation payment. This financial disagreement led to his decision to redshirt for the remainder of the season and enter the transfer portal in December.
The situation became even more complicated when UNLV’s athletic department issued a statement denying any involvement in what they described as “pay-for-play” activities, which would violate NCAA rules and Nevada state law. The university also declined to meet the demands of Sluka’s representatives, who had been negotiating for the $100,000 payment they believed was promised. As a result, Sluka will now leave the team, marking a significant blow to UNLV’s ambitions for the season.
The Bigger Picture: NIL’s Wild West
This incident with Matthew Sluka at UNLV is just the latest example of the chaos surrounding NIL agreements in college sports. The world of NIL is often compared to the “wild wild west,” where student-athletes are left navigating unregulated and often inconsistent promises from schools and collectives. Another domino has fallen in this rapidly evolving space, as athletes continue to allege they have been burned by NIL deals that were not fulfilled.
First, there was the highly publicized case of Jaden Rashada at the University of Florida. Rashada had committed to UF after reportedly being promised a $13.85 million NIL deal. When the deal fell through, Rashada sued Florida and head coach Billy Napier, alleging that he had been defrauded of millions. Now, this player at UNLV finds himself in a similar situation, over an apparent verbal contract that will likely not hold much weight in the court system.
A Call for Reform
This incident, like Rashada’s situation, will hopefully be a turning point for state lawmakers and athletic conferences to mandate that all NIL contracts must be filed with a designated party, such as a clearinghouse with the conference or the state. These changes would help provide transparency and accountability in the NIL space, protecting both the athletes and the schools involved.
As the NIL landscape continues to evolve, it’s crucial that universities begin hiring law firms to educate their student-athletes, staff, and collectives about NIL legalities and rights, rather than relying on companies that focus solely on marketing and overlook important details like finances and state laws. The current system leaves athletes vulnerable to unfulfilled promises, and reforms are necessary to safeguard their interests and ensure that all parties involved understand their legal obligations.
The Rebels will now move forward on their undefeated season without their starting quarterback, relying on other key players to step up in Sluka’s absence. While the controversy surrounding his departure may linger, the team’s focus will remain on continuing their successful season.
What’s Next for UNLV?
Despite the setback of losing their starting quarterback, UNLV will press forward with their undefeated season. The Rebels are currently 3-0 and have already pulled off upset wins against Big 12 programs like Houston and Kansas. Coach Barry Odom will now rely on senior quarterbacks Hajj-Malik Williams and Cameron Friel to lead the team as they enter Mountain West conference play.
Williams, who transferred from Campbell University, is an experienced player who holds Campbell’s all-time passing record with over 8,000 career yards. Friel, on the other hand, has started 10 games for UNLV over the past two seasons. Both quarterbacks will need to step up as the Rebels aim to maintain their strong start and make a push for the Mountain West title.
A Defining Moment for NIL
As NIL continues to reshape the landscape of college sports, incidents like this one with Sluka at UNLV may become more common unless reforms are put in place. Without clear guidelines, universities and athletes alike face uncertainty when it comes to fulfilling NIL agreements. The hope is that these high-profile cases will serve as a turning point, prompting changes that will create more stability in the NIL marketplace.
In the meantime, the Rebels will continue their season without Sluka, relying on their depth at quarterback to navigate the challenges ahead. With a key matchup against Fresno State looming, UNLV will have to adapt quickly to keep their undefeated season alive.







