Pitt Completes Historic Comeback Over SMU
A Game of Two Halves: Pitt’s Remarkable Turnaround
In one of the most astonishing comebacks in NCAA women’s basketball history, the Pittsburgh Panthers rallied from a 32-point deficit to defeat the SMU Mustangs 72-59 on Sunday afternoon. The record-tying victory unfolded at the Petersen Events Center, showcasing a dramatic reversal of fortune as Pitt outscored SMU 54-10 in the second half. This remarkable effort tied the largest comeback in NCAA women’s basketball history, matching Texas State’s 2006 overtime victory over UTSA.
The Panthers struggled early, trailing 32-7 by the end of the first quarter and 49-18 at halftime. However, a lockdown defensive effort in the second half, combined with efficient scoring, allowed Pitt to stage their historic comeback. The victory not only marked a milestone for the team but also demonstrated their resilience and determination under pressure.
SMU’s Dominance in the First Half
SMU came out of the gates strong, overwhelming Pitt with their aggressive play on both ends of the court. Their hot shooting helped them establish a commanding lead, as they drained 10 of their first 19 three-point attempts. Junior guard Nya Robertson was unstoppable in the first half, scoring 21 points and hitting four three-pointers. Her offensive explosion was complemented by solid rebounding from Jessica Peterson, who secured 11 boards, and Kaysia Woods, who added nine points and seven rebounds.
SMU’s defense played a key role in their first-half dominance, holding Pitt to just 8% shooting from the field in the first quarter. The Mustangs forced Pitt into tough shots and controlled the tempo of the game, building their largest lead of 32 points late in the second quarter. By halftime, SMU appeared to have the game well in hand, with their offense firing on all cylinders and their defense shutting down the Panthers.
Pitt’s Historic Second Half
What unfolded in the second half was nothing short of extraordinary. Pitt’s defense completely stifled SMU, holding the Mustangs scoreless for the entire third quarter. This unprecedented defensive effort marked the first time in program history that the Panthers allowed zero points in a quarter. The defensive lockdown provided the momentum needed to ignite Pitt’s offense, which had struggled mightily in the first half.
Led by redshirt sophomore Mikayla Johnson and graduate center Khadija Faye, Pitt clawed their way back into the game. Johnson, who finished with a team-high 22 points, hit timely shots from beyond the arc to fuel the comeback. Faye dominated in the paint, scoring 12 of her 21 points in the third quarter alone and tying her career high with six blocks. Their combined effort energized the Panthers and sparked a remarkable 31-0 run that tied the game early in the fourth quarter.
Junior guard Marley Washenitz also played a critical role, contributing 14 points and hitting key three-pointers during Pitt’s run. Senior guard Brooklynn Miles facilitated the offense with eight assists, ensuring the team maintained their rhythm as they chipped away at SMU’s lead. By the end of the third quarter, Pitt had cut the deficit to just three points, setting the stage for a thrilling finish.
The Fourth Quarter: Sealing the Comeback
The fourth quarter began with a three-pointer from MaKayla Elmore, which tied the game at 49 and capped Pitt’s 31-0 run. The Panthers continued to press their advantage, with Washenitz and Elmore hitting clutch shots to put Pitt ahead. Faye’s inside presence and Johnson’s ability to finish through contact kept the momentum firmly on Pitt’s side.
SMU briefly regained the lead in the early stages of the fourth quarter, but their offensive struggles persisted. The Mustangs missed their final 21 two-point attempts and managed just two field goals in the second half. Pitt’s defense remained relentless, forcing turnovers and limiting SMU to contested shots. As the minutes ticked down, the Panthers extended their lead, closing the game on a 6-0 run to secure their place in NCAA history.
SMU’s Second-Half Collapse
After a near-flawless first half, SMU’s offense unraveled in the second. The Mustangs shot a dismal 7% from the field after halftime, going 2-for-28 and missing all their two-point attempts in the final three quarters. Nya Robertson, who had been the team’s offensive spark in the first half, managed just two points in the second. SMU’s inability to adapt to Pitt’s defensive adjustments ultimately sealed their fate.
Despite the loss, SMU showed glimpses of their potential, particularly in the first half. Jessica Peterson’s rebounding and Robertson’s scoring showcased their ability to compete at a high level. However, their lack of consistency and inability to maintain their offensive rhythm proved costly in the face of Pitt’s relentless pressure.
Statistical Highlights and Takeaways
Pitt’s defensive performance in the third quarter was historic, as they held SMU scoreless for 10 minutes, a feat rarely seen at any level of basketball. Offensively, the Panthers shot 59% from the field in the second half and made 16 of their final 24 attempts. This turnaround highlighted their ability to execute under pressure and capitalize on their defensive stops.
For SMU, the game served as a harsh reminder of the importance of maintaining focus and composure throughout all four quarters. Their first-half performance demonstrated their potential as a high-scoring team, but their second-half collapse exposed areas that need improvement, particularly in offensive execution against defensive adjustments.
Looking Ahead
The victory improved Pitt’s record to 9-9 overall and 1-4 in the ACC, providing a much-needed boost of confidence as they prepare to face NC State on Thursday. The Panthers will look to build on this momentum and continue their push for a strong finish in conference play.
For SMU, the loss dropped them to 10-7 overall and 2-3 in the ACC. The Mustangs will need to regroup quickly as they face North Carolina in their next matchup. Despite the setback, their first-half dominance against Pitt highlights their potential to compete with top-tier teams.
This game will be remembered as a testament to the unpredictability and excitement of college basketball. Pitt’s unprecedented comeback not only tied an NCAA record but also underscored the importance of resilience, teamwork, and never giving up, no matter how dire the circumstances.







