NCAA Transfer Portal: Either You Love It or Hate It
The NCAA Transfer Portal was the talk of the town following the 2018 football season when some marque players such as Jalen Hurts of Oklahoma, Justin Fields of Ohio State, and Tate Martell of Miami. Now that the season is at its midpoint we see some programs such as Ohio State, Oklahoma, and SMU, it has been a game changer for them this season. Teams like Miami who looked like the winners of the transfer portal in the offseason have not reaped the benefits of it like one would have predicted now (2-3) on the season with many wondering if they will even be bowl eligible.
As we discussed earlier this week, SMU (6-0) brought in 35 players from the transfer portal and the dividends have paid off with the Mustangs looking like this season's Cinderella team for the Group of 5 with an unblemished record. If SMU makes a New Years Six Bowl look for others arguing that the transfer portal should be eliminated or be restricted so fewer student athletes can transfer.
The Losers of the Transfer Portal
One proponent to end the transfer portal will be Rutgers University who saw its two star players announce last week that they will be wrapping up their Rutgers career 4 games into the season and entering into transfer portal for greener pastures. This is not the first time this year Rutgers saw one of its best player walk out the door because in January, Jonah Jackson, a key piece to the Scarlet Knights took his talents to conference foe Ohio State. The transferring to greener pastures has not been immune to the FBS level because this past weekend Caylin Newton, the star quarterback for Howard University (FCS), announced he wanted to be part of a winning program, so he called it quits after the fourth game of the season entering his name into the transfer portal.
Player Freedom
The transfer portal has created player freedom that the most coaches will cringe at because if a player gets beat out by another player for a starting role or the season starts off rocky, the easy answer is to transfer. The trickle down affect from this will be that we may not see teams built like the old USC's or the Miami teams of the past when it was a next man up mentality. There is even an argument that the powers of college football like Alabama, Ohio State, Oklahoma, and Clemson will only continue to dominate the competition. As a student athlete, if you know a team is losing a key player to graduation or the NFL why not transfer to have the opportunity to play for a national championship or build your draft stock where scouts campout at weekly. The number of scouts to be at one Alabama game is more than some teams across the country may see in years if ever.
Will the Transfer Portal Last?
Many experts will tell you that the transfer portal is here to stay, so long as the Power 5 conferences do not give the NCAA an ultimatum to end it and television ratings do not drop. If one of the two factors does not occur then do not expect the outcry from the other conferences to make much of an impact to the NCAA decision makers. Right now, student athletes have the momentum of society going in their favor from the transfer portal to California passing the law allowing student athletes to get paid for their likeness being used by others. January is usually when things heat up outside of the football field with politics so until then we can enjoy the transfer portal while we have it.







